In hypothetical 5-year backtests to Nov 2026, after costs, Ichimoku beat buy & hold on 34 of 91 famous assets
Published ·Updated
The more complete a rule looks, the more it is worth checking whether the completeness holds up — and nothing on a chart looks more complete than Ichimoku. Its cloud and its web of lines promise trend, momentum and support all at once, an all-in-one system, which is a big part of the draw. But the signal you actually trade is far simpler than the picture: it goes long while price holds above the cloud and steps aside when price closes below it — a trend/regime filter. So here it is on the asset you care about, run the honest way the whole site measures: costs on every trade, every signal waiting for its bar to close, the benchmark always just buying and holding the same asset. One honest catch up front — the cloud is drawn ahead of price, which makes it look forward-looking, but it is built entirely from past highs and lows, so it lags every turn by design. Here is the whole glass: every famous asset, every winner and every loser.
So — does Ichimoku work?
On the honest evidence: mostly, no. Across the 91 famous assets with enough trades and history to judge, the Ichimoku cloud rule beat buy & hold on 34 of them — 37%, so 57 of the 91 did better simply held. That's a shade above the 33% we measure across every rule — but read that carefully. These are famous names that mostly trended over the window, and a trend/regime filter flatters itself on a trend, so a higher rate here is a fact about this survivorship-selected panel, not evidence that Ichimoku “works”. The typical run didn't win either: its median came in at -23 pts versus buy & hold over the window. A handful of real winners exist — that's why the question is worth asking honestly — but a beat on this panel is inflated by survivorship, by a mostly-trending set of names, and by the many lines and settings you could have read after the fact; a loss counts against the rule in a way a win does not count for it. The burden of proof is on the rule, and an elaborate-looking chart is not that proof.
These are famous names that still trade today. Assets that delisted, went bankrupt or (for crypto) died or were rug-pulled aren't in the set (survivorship bias) — and that history isn't available from the free public data this tool runs on — so this rate isn't a representative base rate for every asset that has ever traded.
Where it shone, where it died
Forget the headline average — the honest signal is in the spread. One unchanged Ichimoku rule turns into a triumph on one asset and a wreck on the next, decided entirely by which asset you happened to point it at.
Solana — Ichimoku beat buy & hold by +147 pts here, holding above the cloud through a long clean trend and stepping to cash before the worst of the turn. That is as much a statement about that asset's trend as about the rule's skill — you couldn't have known in advance which asset would oblige.
Micron Technology — Ichimoku came in at -703 pts versus buy & hold. Around a flat cloud price crosses in and out, so the rule flips late near local highs and lows, gets chopped on the whipsaws, and pays costs on every one — the classic way a trend filter bleeds when there is no trend.
Five lines, and a shallower fall they didn’t earn
The pitch for all those components is coverage — trend, momentum and support in one picture, risk built in. So the test that matters is the one thing a built-in risk layer should buy: a shallower drawdown. Here the rule did sidestep part of the fall more often than not — on 72 of 91 judged assets its deepest hole was shallower than holding's. But that is what stepping to cash does for any exit rule — less time in the market is less drawdown and also less return — not something the five lines earned, and it is this window's behaviour, not a promise it repeats.
These drawdowns come from famous names that still trade today. Names that delisted, went bankrupt or (for crypto) died aren't in the set — and those include the deepest holes of all — so the full real-world range of drawdowns is wider than the slice shown here. And these are the strategies' drawdowns, not the assets': an exit-based rule can sidestep part of a fall a buy-and-holder would have sat through.
Why Ichimoku looks like it always works
- • All those lines sell completeness, not foresight. Ichimoku bundles five things into one picture, so it feels like it covers everything at once. But the signal this study actually trades — and the one part that collapses to a single clean, testable rule — is the cloud regime, and that is a plain lagging trend filter; the extra lines add more to read, not more edge.
- • The cloud looks like it predicts; it only echoes. The Kumo is drawn ahead of price, which makes it look forward-looking — but it is past highs and lows shifted forward, so it lags every real turn, and “price held the cloud as support” is something you can only confirm once the move is already over.
- • You get shown the one chart where price rode the cloud. Picking the asset and the dates after you already know Ichimoku looked good there is hindsight dressed up as proof. The whole glass above is what's left when you can't choose.
- • A regime filter needs a regime. Holding above the cloud pays only while a trend persists; in a sideways range price crosses the cloud back and forth, the rule whipsaws in and out for a string of small losses, and pays costs each time.
Nothing here is filtered — every Ichimoku run is public, the wins sitting right next to the wrecks. Read the full scoreboard, then point the cloud at the asset you actually care about and watch which side of the line it lands on.
Figures are computed live from simulated backtests over roughly the last five years and update as new bars close. “Ichimoku” here is the signature cloud (Kumo) regime rule — long while price holds above the displaced cloud, flat when it closes below, and neutral inside the cloud (holding the prior position) — with the cloud built only from past data. Other settings and the full line system behave differently, which is the point; you can test them yourself. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. This is an educational, analytical tool — not investment advice, and not a recommendation to buy or sell anything. You make all decisions and execute on your own broker.
Does the Ichimoku cloud strategy actually work?
Measured the honest way — the cloud's return against simply owning the asset, real costs charged, the cloud read only on closed bars — most Ichimoku runs trail buy & hold, and the cloud finishes ahead on only a real minority of names. Where the cloud does win, the win traces to the asset's trend hauling a lagging cloud uphill, not to foresight in the Kumo. Burden of proof stays on the rule, and a chart crowded with Ichimoku lines is not that proof.
Why does the Ichimoku cloud lag price?
Because the cloud, or Kumo, is drawn ahead of price, which makes the cloud look forward-looking — but the cloud is built only from past highs and lows, so the cloud can only echo a move after it has already begun. The conversion and base lines are averages of old prices too. Even 'price held the cloud as support' reads true only after the turn, which is why the Ichimoku cloud always lags the real reversal.
Do the extra Ichimoku lines add an edge over a plain trend filter?
This is the core of Ichimoku's appeal, and its illusion. The cloud layers conversion, base, lagging and leading-span lines into the same view, so the cloud seems to read trend, momentum, support — all at once in the cloud. But only the cloud regime collapses to a single, testable rule — long above the cloud, flat below the cloud — a plain lagging trend filter. Across honest backtests the full Ichimoku system clears buy & hold as seldom as the barest rule — the Ichimoku cloud's completeness buys no edge in the result.
Does the Ichimoku cloud give consistent results across different assets?
No — with Ichimoku the cloud's honest signal is the spread, not the average. The same unchanged cloud rule is a triumph where the cloud rode a clean trend and a wreck where price chopped across the cloud, decided by the market the Kumo met, not by the rule. A regime filter needs a regime: where price keeps crossing a flat cloud, the Ichimoku rule flips late, gets chopped on each cloud re-cross, and bleeds cost on every whipsaw through the cloud. Which asset will trend enough to flatter the cloud cannot be known in advance, so even where the cloud beat holding, that win belongs to an asset that out-trended the cloud, not to the cloud itself.
- Does RSI actually work?overbought/oversold reversion — whipsawed in a trend
- Does MACD actually work?a momentum crossover that lands after the move
- Does the TTM Squeeze work?a coiled spring blind to direction
- Does Heikin-Ashi work?the calm chart that hid the real drawdown
- Do Bollinger Bands work?one tool, two opposite trades