Stratsemble
Learn · a data study

In hypothetical 5-year backtests to Nov 2026, after costs, MACD beat buy & hold on 32 of 91 famous assets

Published ·Updated

Find a rule that genuinely beats buy & hold and you've found something rare and worth everything — so here's MACD, tested honestly on the asset you care about rather than taken on reputation: the classic trend strategy — it goes long when the MACD line (the gap between a fast 12-day and a slow 26-day moving average) crosses above its 9-day signal line, and steps back to cash when it falls below — measured exactly the way the rest of the site measures: every fill charged fees and slippage, no signal acting until its bar has closed, the benchmark always just buying the same asset and holding it. Nothing cherry-picked, no window hand-chosen. MACD is a trend rule — the mirror image of RSI, trying to ride a move rather than fade it. Here's the whole glass: every famous asset, every winner and every loser.

Beat buy & hold
32
Lagged buy & hold
59
Share that beat
35%
Every strategy, for context
33%
share that beat, all rules

So — does MACD work?

On the honest evidence: mostly, no. Across the 91 famous assets with enough trades and history to judge, the MACD rule beat buy & hold on 32 of them — 35%, so 59 of the 91 did better simply held. That's a shade above the 33% we measure across every rule — but read that carefully. These are famous names that mostly trended over the window, and a trend-following rule flatters itself on a trend, so a slightly higher rate here is a fact about this survivorship-selected panel, not evidence that MACD “works”. The typical MACD run didn't win either: its median result came in at -32 pts versus buy & hold over the window. A handful of real winners exist — that's exactly why the question is worth asking honestly — but a beat on this panel is inflated by survivorship, by a mostly-trending set of names, and by the many variants you could have tried; a loss counts against MACD in a way a win does not count for it. The burden of proof is on the rule, and “it looked great on one chart” is not that proof.

These are famous names that still trade today. Assets that delisted, went bankrupt or (for crypto) died or were rug-pulled aren't in the set (survivorship bias) — and that history isn't available from the free public data this tool runs on — so this rate isn't a representative base rate for every asset that has ever traded.

Where it shone, where it died

Forget the headline average for a moment — the honest signal is in the spread. One unchanged MACD rule turns into a triumph on one asset and a wreck on the next, decided entirely by which asset you happened to point it at.

Its best run

Tesla — MACD beat buy & hold by +245 pts here. A trend rule looks brilliant on an asset that trended cleanly and then dropped hard: MACD rode the move and its cross flipped it to cash before the worst of the fall. That is as much a statement about that asset's trend as about MACD's skill — you couldn't have known in advance which asset would oblige.

Its worst run

Micron Technology — MACD came in -695 pts behind buy & hold. In a choppy, sideways stretch the MACD line crosses its signal back and forth: the rule buys late near local highs and sells late near local lows, gets chopped up on the whipsaws, and pays costs on every one — the classic way a trend rule bleeds when there is no trend.

That inconsistency is the answer to “does MACD work”: the outcome belongs to the asset and its regime, not to the indicator. MACD can help on something that trends cleanly and hurt badly on something that chops sideways — and nothing in the past tells you which future you're about to get.

The round-trip tax: how often it committed to a trade

MACD acts on every crossover, and every round trip costs. Across the judged assets the rule made a median of 49 round trips — each a buy and a later sell that pays spread and fees — against the single buy-and-hold decision it is measured against, and on its busiest name (Bitcoin) it turned over 68 times. Those costs are already inside the excess figures above — this isn't a second penalty — but they are the quiet tax a rule pays for trading on every signal instead of sitting still.

That count is churn, which the census measures; it is not a measure of lateness, which it doesn't. Lateness is a separate, structural fact: MACD acts on smoothed averages, so its cross can only turn after price already has. The two compound — a rule that both trades often and reacts a step behind — but only the round-trip count above is a number we measured.

Why MACD looks like it always works

  • • You get shown the one chart where the crosses lined up. Choosing the asset and the dates after you already know MACD looked good there is hindsight dressed up as proof. The whole glass above is what's left when you can't choose.
  • • The costs are usually hidden. MACD flips more often than a plain moving-average crossover — that's the point of the faster signal — so fees and slippage on every entry and exit bite harder. The friction was always real; most demos just leave it out.
  • • A trend rule needs a trend. MACD's core assumption — that a move keeps going — simply fails in a sideways range, where it whipsaws in and out for a string of small losses, and by design it lags every real turn because it is built on smoothed averages. The same failure shows up on every choppy worst-case asset.
See it, then test your own

Nothing here is filtered — every MACD run is public, the wins sitting right next to the wrecks. Read the full MACD scoreboard, then point the rule at the asset you actually care about and watch which side of the line it lands on.

Figures are computed live from simulated backtests over roughly the last five years and update as new bars close. “MACD” here is the standard 12/26/9 rule, going long when the MACD line is above its signal line and flat when below; other settings behave differently, which is the point — you can test any of them yourself. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. This is an educational, analytical tool — not investment advice, and not a recommendation to buy or sell anything. You make all decisions and execute on your own broker.

Does the MACD strategy actually work?

Scored the honest way — against each asset's own buy & hold, after costs, rather than just whether price rose after a crossover — most MACD runs on famous assets trail simply holding. A real minority come out ahead, but a trend rule flatters itself on an asset that already trended, so a beat tends to be the market's doing, not proof the indicator forecasts anything. The burden of proof sits on the rule, and one good-looking chart is never that proof.

Why does the MACD indicator lag the market?

Because it is built entirely from moving averages — smoothed, backward-looking summaries of past prices. The MACD line is the distance between a fast and a slow average, and the signal line smooths that distance again, a third layer of delay. A crossover cannot fire until price has already moved enough to drag those averages across each other, so the rule marks a turn well after it has begun rather than anticipating it.

Is the MACD crossover dependable across different markets?

Not in the sense of a stable edge. One unchanged MACD rule can win handsomely on an asset that trended cleanly and bleed on the next one that chopped sideways, and nothing in the past says which regime arrives next. The outcome swings with the asset and its trend rather than any dependable skill in the indicator — and the fame of the MACD name is a fact about its popularity, not evidence of an edge.

Does the MACD strategy work in a sideways market?

This is where it struggles most. A trend rule needs a trend; in a flat, choppy range the MACD and signal lines cross back and forth with no real move to ride. Each false crossover is a round trip that buys late near a local high and sells late near a local low, paying spread and fees every time — the string of small losses the mechanism produces precisely because there is no trend to follow.

More from this series — does each famous indicator work?

Indicator and strategy names identify the published rule being tested; no affiliation with, or endorsement by, any person or trademark owner is implied.