Stratsemble
Learn · a data study

In hypothetical 5-year backtests to Nov 2026, after costs, RSI beat buy & hold on 29 of 91 famous assets

Published ·Updated

Find a rule that genuinely beats buy & hold and you've found something rare and worth everything — so here's RSI, tested honestly on the asset you care about, not read off one flattering chart: the classic mean-reversion rule — it buys when the 14-period RSI drops into oversold territory (below 30), and steps back out once it recovers past the midline (above 55) — run the same honest way as everything on this site: fees and slippage on every fill, only ever acting on a bar that has closed, always measured against simply buying and holding. No cherry-picked chart, no favourable window — so a beat here is honestly won, not a trick of the window; a single backtest beat still has to prove itself forward. Here's the whole glass: every famous asset, every winner and every loser.

Beat buy & hold
29
Lagged buy & hold
62
Share that beat
32%
Every strategy, for context
32%
share that beat, all rules

So — does RSI work?

On the honest evidence: mostly, no. Across the 91 famous assets with enough trades and history to judge, the RSI rule beat buy & hold on 29 of them — 32%. The typical RSI run didn't just lose narrowly either: its median result came in at -24 pts versus buy & hold over the window. A handful of real winners exist — that's exactly why the question is worth asking honestly — but the base rate says the burden of proof is on RSI, and “it looked great on one chart” is not that proof.

These are famous names that still trade today. Assets that delisted, went bankrupt or (for crypto) died or were rug-pulled aren't in the set (survivorship bias) — and that history isn't available from the free public data this tool runs on — so this rate isn't a representative base rate for every asset that has ever traded.

Where it shone, where it died

The most useful thing about the whole glass isn't the average — it's the spread. The exact same RSI rule, unchanged, swings from a big beat to a catastrophe depending purely on which asset you point it at.

Its best run

Cardano — RSI beat buy & hold by +130 pts here. Where the timing genuinely added value it was usually by sitting out a decline the buy-and-holder rode down, then buying back after the drop — as much a statement about that asset's fall as about RSI's skill.

Its worst run

Micron Technology — RSI came in -822 pts behind buy & hold. On a strong, sustained trend the rule sells the winner early and sits out the run — the single worst thing you can do to a trending asset.

That inconsistency is the honest answer to “does RSI work”: it isn't a property of the indicator, it's a property of the asset and the regime. RSI can help on something range-bound and hurt badly on something that trends — and you can't know which future you're in from the past.

The mean-reversion trap: RSI sat out the biggest climb

Take the single asset that climbed hardest here — Micron Technology, where simply holding returned +876 pts. RSI finished -822 pts behind just holding it: the oversold-buy, recover-sell rule sold the strength and sat out the run. That is what fading a trend does by construction — a reversion rule caps its own upside exactly where a buy-and-holder wins most. It is the same name the worst-run card above shows, seen from the climb side.

That is one case drawn from the spread above, not a second measurement — the honest unit stays the whole glass of judged assets, losses and all.

Why RSI looks like it always works

  • • You get shown the one chart where it nailed the tops and bottoms. Picking the asset and the window after you know RSI worked there is hindsight, not evidence. The whole glass above is what you get when you can't choose.
  • • The costs are usually hidden. RSI trades a lot. Fees and slippage on every entry and exit quietly turn many “profitable” RSI rules negative — the friction was always real; most demos just leave it out.
  • • Oversold can stay oversold. RSI's core assumption — that a stretched move reverts — simply fails in a strong trend, which is precisely when buy & hold does best. That's the same failure showing up on every worst-case asset.
See it, then test your own

Every RSI backtest is public — winners and losers, no cherry-picking. Read the whole RSI scoreboard, then run RSI on the asset you care about and see honestly which side of the line it lands on.

Figures are computed live from simulated backtests over roughly the last five years and update as new bars close. “RSI” here is the standard 14-period oscillator, buying an oversold reading (below 30) and exiting on the recovery back through the midline (above 55); other settings behave differently, which is the point — you can test any of them yourself. Hypothetical / simulated results — Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. This is an educational, analytical tool — not investment advice, and not a recommendation to buy or sell anything. You make all decisions and execute on your own broker.

Does the RSI strategy actually work?

Measured the honest way — the classic oversold-entry, recovery-exit rule run against each asset's own buy & hold, after costs — it lags holding far more often than it clears it. A real minority of assets do finish ahead, but that is usually the asset itself dropping in a way the timing happened to sidestep, not the oscillator foreseeing the move. The burden of proof stays on the rule, and one flattering chart is not that proof.

Why does the RSI strategy lag buy and hold?

Two mechanics pull it back. The rule is mean-reversion, so it sells into strength and sits out the back half of a sustained climb — fading the very trends where holding gains the most — while its frequent round-trips each pay a fee and slippage. On a strongly trending asset the oscillator keeps calling a top too soon, and the longer that trend runs the further behind holding the rule finishes.

Is the RSI strategy consistent across different assets?

No — it is strikingly inconsistent. The same unchanged rule swings from a clear beat to an outright disaster purely with the asset and the market regime it meets: it can help on something range-bound and hurt badly on something that trends. That spread is the honest answer — the outcome is a property of the asset and the regime, not of the oscillator, and a famous indicator name carries no edge by itself. Which future an asset is about to hand over cannot be read off its past.

Why does RSI look impressive on a single chart but fail in testing?

Because a single chart is chosen after the fact. Pointing the rule at the one asset and stretch of history where it nailed the tops and bottoms is hindsight, not evidence — the whole set of judged assets, losers kept in, is what remains once that choice is taken away. Its core assumption, that a stretched move snaps back, simply breaks down in a strong trend, which is precisely when holding does best, so the same failure resurfaces on every worst case.

More from this series — does each famous indicator work?

Indicator and strategy names identify the published rule being tested; no affiliation with, or endorsement by, any person or trademark owner is implied.