Stratsemble
Open data · release 2026-09-25

The Honest Backtest Census: How Often Famous Strategies Beat Buy & Hold

Cite this — a dated, frozen figure

How to cite this release

The headline is the stocks-&-ETFs cut (composition-stable). Crypto beats buy & hold far more often on this set, so any all-asset figure runs higher — an overfitting artifact, not an edge.

“As of September 25, 2026, 25 famous, named trading strategies were each backtested on 36 liquid US stocks & ETFs — 900 strategy-asset combinations, of which 839 had enough trades to judge (61 were too thin and excluded). Of those judged, about 86% failed to beat simply buying and holding the same asset over the same 5-year window — net of costs and slippage, with no look-ahead. This is a survivorship-biased set of well-known assets, measured over the full period with no out-of-sample split, against each asset's own buy & hold, and is not significance-tested. These are hypothetical, simulated results, not advice.”

As of September 25, 2026n = 839 judged backtestsliquid US stocks & ETFs5-year windowfigures free to reuse under CC BY 4.0Full methodologyRelease 2026-09-25

Permanent DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.22974116 — archived on Zenodo, CC BY 4.0. Cite this release by the DOI or the URL above.

Download the data — free, CC BY 4.0

Reuse freely with attribution. Aggregate rates only — no per-trade records, equity curves, or strategy parameters (see the README for what is and isn't here).

By asset class

ClassJudgedBeatFailed
Stocks & ETFs83914%86%
Crypto (context)25764%36%
All (context)1,09626%74%

The stocks & ETFs row is the headline. Crypto and “all” are context only — a small, volatile, survivorship-biased sample; an overfitting artifact, not a demonstrated edge, and not significance-tested.

By strategy — all 25, on stocks & ETFs

Tested to our published open method v1

This is our own research — every one of the 25 famous strategies, run whole-glass to the same published open method, winners and losers alike. Every one has a negative median excess — the typical run of each lagged simply holding. The median is a cross-asset central tendency, not a forecast; differences between strategies are within sampling noise on a small, correlated, survivorship-biased set. Open any one to study its cells across assets; most re-load into the no-code builder to run as your own.

StrategyJudgedFailedMedian excessStudy
200-Day MA Regime3669%-22%Study →
52-Week High Breakout3093%-77%Study →
ADX / DMI Trend3683%-81%Study →
Aroon3686%-49%Study →
Awesome Oscillator3686%-54%Study →
Bollinger Band Breakout3686%-69%Study →
Bollinger Band Reversion3692%-70%Study →
Commodity Channel Index3689%-66%Study →
Chaikin Money Flow3692%-80%Study →
Connors RSI-23689%-73%Study →
Donchian Breakout3686%-54%Study →
Heikin-Ashi Trend3692%-84%Study →
Ichimoku Cloud3689%-64%Study →
Keltner Channel Breakout3683%-75%Study →
MACD3686%-75%Study →
Money Flow Index3080%-46%Study →
Time-Series Momentum3675%-36%Study →
Moving Average Crossover2391%-42%Study →
On-Balance Volume3681%-69%Study →
Parabolic SAR3689%-84%Study →
RSI Reversion3686%-77%Study →
Stochastic RSI3686%-47%Study →
Stochastic Oscillator3683%-65%Study →
SuperTrendsmall sample0——Study →
Vortex Indicator3692%-73%Study →

Drawdowns — strategy vs buy & hold

Strategies often drew down less than holding — but that is mostly sitting in cash(avoidance, not skill), and on stocks & ETFs they still failed 86% of the time. Median maximum drawdown across judged combinations (a negative fraction of equity):

Stocks & ETFs
Strategy median: -27%
Buy & hold median: -35%
Crypto (context)
Strategy median: -68%
Buy & hold median: -85%

Overfitting artifact on a small survivorship-biased sample, not an edge.

All (context)
Strategy median: -33%
Buy & hold median: -45%

Overfitting artifact on a small survivorship-biased sample, not an edge.

About this release

As of
September 25, 2026
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22974116
Window
2021-09-26 → 2026-09-25 (5 years)
Sample
25 strategies × 36 liquid US stocks & ETFs = 900 combinations; 839 judged, 61 too thin
Benchmark
each asset's own buy & hold
Costs
0.05% per side, next-bar fills, costs and slippage on, no look-ahead
Licence
CC BY 4.0
Release / version
2026-09-25 / v1